Hello {{first_name|Storyteller}}.

This week's case file is a post I've written myself, more than once. A chief executive shares a good year on LinkedIn, gets a few dozen likes, and nobody who could actually help gets in touch.

If you post as a leader, of a charity or of a CSR or social impact team inside a company, this one's for you.

Every case is an anonymised composite, drawn from many conversations I've had with charities and social impact teams over the last two years.

THIS WEEK'S BIG IDEA
Case file 6: the post that reported everything

The case (composite)

  • The organisation: a carers' charity in a market town. Twelve staff, supporting unpaid carers: people looking after a partner, a parent or a child.

  • The leader: the chief executive, Ruth (not her real name). She posts on her own LinkedIn most months, usually when something's happened.

  • The post: the week the annual report came out.

  • What happened: 52 reactions and six comments. Almost all from staff, trustees, two funders and other chief executives she knows. "Congratulations!" "Brilliant work." No messages, and nobody asked how to get involved.

  • What Ruth thought: it did fine. It's what her posts usually get.

The version most people would have

❝

Delighted to share our impact report for 2025/26.

This year we supported 1,240 unpaid carers, delivered 3,100 hours of respite breaks and launched our first young carers' group.

None of this would be possible without our incredible staff, volunteers, trustees, funders and partners. Thank you all. I'm so proud of what we've achieved together.

Read the full report here: [link]

What's wrong with it

Every line is true. It's warm, it's accurate, and it thanks the right people.

It just doesn't tell you what Ruth thinks.

The post is in the organisation's voice, the one that goes in the annual report and the funding application, with "I" added at the top. On a feed, that voice gives a reader nothing to follow. There's no opinion to agree with, no worry to share, nothing to push back on. People admire it with a like, and scroll on.

The thank-you list does the same thing. Thanking five groups of people is kind, and it names nobody.

The numbers have nobody in them either. 1,240 carers is a lot. It doesn't tell a reader why they should care, or what they could do about it.

Plenty of people probably saw it. LinkedIn makes sure of that. But nothing in it gave someone who could actually help a reason to get in touch. And because nothing went wrong, she'll post the same way next month.

None of this is Ruth's fault. Chief executives spend all day writing in the organisation's voice, so it's the voice that comes out. Saying what you actually think in public feels exposing, and some boards are nervous about it. Nobody's ever been told off for thanking their volunteers.

A better way to think about it

Nobody follows an update.

On LinkedIn, leading means telling people what you've come to believe, and giving them somewhere to stand next to you. The report can still be in the post. It just can't be the whole post.

So try this test. Take your name off the post. Could anyone tell it was yours?

If not, you've posted the organisation's news with your face on it.

Then three actions:

  • Pick one fact, not all of them. The one that surprised you, worried you or changed your mind.

  • Say what you think about it. One sentence that starts with "I", and that someone could disagree with.

  • Say what's unfinished. What you're worried about, or haven't got right yet. It's the line that makes people want to help.

The rewrite

Ruth went back to her notes. One thing came up again and again in the year: almost every carer who came to the charity said they hadn't known it existed until someone mentioned it. Some had been caring for years.

❝

Almost every carer who came to us this year told us the same thing. They didn't know we existed until someone mentioned us. Some had been caring for years by then.

We supported 1,240 carers last year, and I'm proud of that. What I can't stop thinking about is how long most of them waited. I think we're too hard to find, and I think that's our job to fix.

GP surgeries, pharmacies and schools see carers every week. Most don't know to point people our way, and we haven't been good at asking them.

If you work in a surgery, a pharmacy or a school round here, could I have 20 minutes of your time? Message me and I'll come to you.

Look at what's different.

It opens with what carers kept saying.

There's one number, and Ruth says why it isn't enough.

There's a view in it, in a sentence someone could disagree with. A trustee might. So might a commissioner who thinks the charity is already well known.

She admits what the charity hasn't done well. That's uncomfortable, and it's the reason a pharmacist reading it might reply.

And it's written for one kind of reader, with one small thing to ask them. (If you want more on the ask itself, Edition 43 covered it.)

The thank-yous haven't disappeared. They can be a post of their own, about one volunteer and what she did this year.

The rewrite doesn't borrow a carer's hardest moment to make people feel something. The feeling comes from Ruth's view, and that's hers to give.

If you're on the other side of the table

If you fund charities, your own posts probably sound like this too: "We're delighted to announce our new grants round." Say what you're hoping to fund more of, and what you learned from the last round. Applicants will read every word.

If you're a CSR or social impact lead, "Proud to renew our partnership with..." tells people you signed something. Say why your company chose this work, and what you're still trying to get right. That's the post another company might learn from.

One thing this case doesn't solve

Some views aren't yours to take alone. If what you think touches on policy, a funder or a partner, talk to your chair before you post. Charities can speak out. A board that finds out from LinkedIn is the problem.

Don't fix a flat post with someone else's story. The quickest way to make a post move people is to put a person's worst moment in it. It isn't yours to spend, and it moves people for the wrong reasons. If you do quote someone you support, the usual consent still applies, even for one line.

And a report isn't always wrong. Annual report week is a fine time for one. The trouble starts when every post is one.

A FAVOUR
Could I share what you think?

Most people find a newsletter like this because someone they trust mentions it. I'd like to put a few honest words from readers on my website and socials, so new readers hear from people like them and not just from me.

If this newsletter has helped you with anything, even something small, I'd love a sentence or two. It takes about a minute, and you choose whether your name goes with it.

If something isn't working for you, tell me that too. I read every reply.

THE IMPACT STORYTELLING COLLECTIVE
Somewhere to work on it with others

Saying what you think in public is easier when you've tried it out on people doing the same work first. That's part of what the Impact Storytelling Collective is for: a home for charity and social impact leaders, with live workshops, co-working sessions and honest feedback.

Founding members are joining now and helping me shape it. The waitlist is free, and people on it hear first when more places open.

AI prompt: Put your view back in

This prompt reads a draft post, or your notes for one. It checks whether the post should carry your own view at all, picks the one fact most likely to make someone who could help stop and read, offers you a few views to choose from (or uses yours), and drafts a short post in four parts. It flags anything that could identify someone, any story that isn't yours to tell, and anything your chair should see first. It won't invent facts or quotes.

Before you paste: swap real names for made-up ones, and take out anything else that could identify the people you support.

Copy and paste it into Claude or Gemini.

This AI prompt is accessible to subscribers of this newsletter. It's free to subscribe, and all you need to provide is your email address ↓

Send me your case

Got a post you were proud of that nobody acted on? Or a case study, a funding application or a board report you're not sure about?

Reply to this email, or message me on LinkedIn, and describe it in a few lines. I'll pick some to work through as case files in future editions.

If I use yours, I'll take out anything that could identify you, your organisation or the people you work with, and I'll show you the case before it goes out.

Final thoughts

People will follow you a long way if they know what you think.

Tell them, even if it's only one sentence.

Until next week, please take care.

Warm regards,

Matt Mahmood-Ogston
Award-winning impact storyteller, photographer and charity CEO.
Follow me on LinkedIn for free storytelling examples, guides and fresh thinking.

A few ways you can work with me