Hello {{first_name|Storyteller}}.

When a funder last asked whether your best story was typical, what did you say?

Most teams prepare the story and forget the question that comes straight after it. This week's case file is about that question, and the short answer you can have ready before anyone asks.

The case files are staying

For the last four editions I tried a new format: one composite case, what's wrong with it, and the rewrite. I asked whether to keep it, and everyone who voted said yes. So it stays.

Every case is an anonymised composite, drawn from many conversations with charities and social impact teams, then changed so it isn't any one of them.

THIS WEEK'S BIG IDEA
Case file 5: the story with nothing behind it

The case (composite)

  • The organisation: a youth mentoring charity. Eight staff and about 30 volunteer mentors, working with young people who've stopped going to school.

  • The story: Marcus (not his real name). At 15, he'd missed most of a school year. A mentor met him every week for eight months. He's now at college, training to be an electrician. His words, his consent, and a line the team loves: "She was the first adult who didn't give up on me."

  • Where it went: the lead case study in a funding application to a charitable trust, for three more years of mentoring.

  • What happened: the application reached the second stage. Then the trust's grants officer rang with one question: "Is Marcus typical?" The chief executive said "Yes, absolutely", and couldn't say much more. The application wasn't funded. The feedback said the trust couldn't tell how far Marcus's story reflected the rest of the work.

The version most people would have

The case study is a page about Marcus, and it's well written. It ends like this:

❝

Marcus is just one of the many young people whose lives have been changed by our mentors.

The numbers are somewhere else, in a table near the back: 46 young people mentored last year. The team was proud of it.

What's wrong with it

The story's fine. It's just on its own.

"One of the many" is the line doing the most work, and it's the line with the least behind it. A grants officer reads that and has no idea whether Marcus is one of 40 or one of four.

When a funder asks if a story is typical, they're rarely doubting the person. They're asking for the pattern. They want to know whether they'd be funding more of what happened to Marcus, or funding the hope of it.

The table at the back doesn't help. It counts how many young people were mentored, not how many ended up somewhere like Marcus did. And it sits pages away from the story, so nobody reads the two together.

Then the phone call made it worse. Without a number behind it, "Yes, absolutely" sounds like what everyone says.

A better way to think about it

One story is an anecdote until you show the pattern behind it. Funders are trained to discount anecdotes, however moving they are.

So use this test. If someone asked you right now whether this story is typical, what would you say, and how would you know?

If your honest answer is "I think so", the story needs a pattern next to it.

I run a small charity myself, and I know the pull to tidy the ending for a funder. The conversations that have gone best for us are the ones where I've said plainly where things stand: what worked, what didn't, and what we still don't know.

Then three actions:

  • Put a number next to the person. In the same paragraph, not in a table at the back. One number that shows how many people got somewhere similar, out of how many.

  • Say where the number came from. Your own records, a survey, a follow-up call. A few words is enough.

  • Say what you don't know yet. Most teams leave this out. Funders notice, and it's what makes them trust everything else you've said.

The rewrite

Here's the same case study, rewritten. It's still a composite.

❝

At 15, Marcus had missed most of a school year. His mentor, Aisha, met him every week for eight months. He's now at college, training to be an electrician.

Marcus is one of 46 young people we mentored last year. Six months after mentoring ended, 29 were back in school, college, training or work. We know because we call every young person at six months. We couldn't reach seven of them, so the real figure could be a little higher or lower.

We don't yet know how many stay on their course to the end. We've started tracking that this year.

Look at what's different.

Marcus still comes first. The reader meets a person before a number.

"One of the many" has gone. In its place is a real pattern, 29 out of 46, sitting in the same paragraph as the story.

The source is one sentence, and anyone could check it.

And the last paragraph says what the charity can't prove yet. It's the line most teams would cut, and it's the one that makes a grants officer believe the rest.

Now when the phone rings and someone asks "Is Marcus typical?", the chief executive has an answer: "Nearly two in three get somewhere like Marcus did. Not all of them, and we've told you which part we're still measuring."

If you're on the other side of the table

If you fund charities, "Is this typical?" is a fair question. To a small team without a data officer, though, it can feel like a trap. Tell applicants up front that you'll ask it, and that "here's what we know, and here's what we don't yet" is a good answer. You'll get more honest applications.

If you're a CSR or social impact lead reporting to your board, the same rule applies to your own stories. One colleague's brilliant volunteering day is an anecdote. Put it next to how many staff took part, how many came back a second time, and what you haven't measured.

One thing this case doesn't solve

If you work with very few people, a pattern can identify them. "Three of the four young women we supported in one town" tells a local reader exactly who they are. With small numbers, keep the pattern general, or leave the place out.

If your work is new, you may not have a pattern yet. Then the honest version is the gap on its own: what you're tracking, and when you'll know. That's still stronger than "one of the many".

A national statistic can show the size of the wider problem, but it can't show that your work is working. Only your own records can do that. If you use one, name the source and check it's current.

This week's question

THE IMPACT STORYTELLING COLLECTIVE
Somewhere to work on it with others

Finding the pattern behind your own stories is easier with someone asking you the funder's questions first. That's part of what the Impact Storytelling Collective is for: a home for charity and social impact leaders, with live workshops, co-working sessions and honest feedback from people doing the same work.

Founding members are joining now and helping me shape it. The waitlist is free, and people on it hear first when more places open.

AI prompt: Show the pattern behind your story

This prompt reads one story and the numbers you have. It checks whether the story should be used to show a pattern at all, finds any vague line like "one of the many", picks the number that best shows how typical the story is (or tells you it's missing), and drafts a short paragraph that puts the person and the pattern together. It flags anything that could identify someone. It won't invent figures, and it won't rewrite your story.

Before you paste: swap real names for made-up ones, and take out anything else that could identify the people you support.

Copy and paste it into Claude or Gemini.

This AI prompt is accessible to subscribers of this newsletter. It's free to subscribe, and all you need to provide is your email address ↓

Send me your case

Got a story that funders loved, and then they asked something you couldn't answer? Or a case study, a funding application or a board report you're not sure about?

Reply to this email, or message me on LinkedIn, and describe it in a few lines. I'll pick some to work through as case files in future editions.

If I use yours, I'll take out anything that could identify you, your organisation or the people you work with, and I'll show you the case before it goes out.

Final thoughts

A funder who asks whether your story is typical is giving you the chance to show it.

Have the answer sitting next to the story before they ask.

Until next week, please take care.

Warm regards,

Matt Mahmood-Ogston
Award-winning impact storyteller, photographer and charity CEO.
Follow me on LinkedIn for free storytelling examples, guides and fresh thinking.

A few ways you can work with me